GB 5310 25MnG vs 20MnG Seamless Steel Tubes: Key Differences

Feb 25, 2025 Leave a message

What GB 5310 Covers

GB 5310 is the Chinese standard for seamless steel tubes for high-pressure boilers and superheaters. Tubes made to this standard sit in the pressure-retaining parts of a boiler, where they carry high-pressure water, steam or flue gas at elevated temperature and must combine strength, toughness and long-term structural stability. The current edition is GB 5310-2017, and grades carry the suffix G to mark boiler service.

Two grades that are frequently compared are 20MnG and 25MnG. They are both manganese-alloyed carbon steel boiler tubes with similar processing, inspection and heat-treatment requirements, so the differences between them come down to carbon level, strength, ductility and the resulting welding and forming behaviour.

How the Grade Designations Are Read

The leading number in a Chinese steel grade of this type is the nominal carbon content expressed in hundredths of a percent, so 20MnG denotes a nominal carbon content of about 0.20 % and 25MnG a nominal carbon content of about 0.25 %. The element symbol that follows shows the principal alloying addition, in this case manganese, and the G suffix confirms that the grade is intended for boiler service. The numbers therefore describe carbon content, not manganese content: both grades carry manganese in the same approximate range, which is what gives them better strength than a plain carbon boiler grade such as 20G.

Chemical Composition Compared

Heat analysis limits for the two grades under GB 5310-2017 are shown below. Note that the carbon range is the main difference between them; manganese, silicon and the residual element limits are essentially the same.

Element, % 20MnG 25MnG
Carbon 0.17 - 0.24 0.22 - 0.30
Silicon 0.17 - 0.37 0.17 - 0.37
Manganese 0.70 - 1.00 0.70 - 1.00
Phosphorus, max 0.025 0.025
Sulphur, max 0.015 0.015

Both grades keep phosphorus and sulphur low to protect hot ductility and weldability, and both limit residual copper, chromium, nickel and molybdenum so that the tube behaves predictably during bending and welding.

Mechanical Properties and Service Behaviour

Minimum room-temperature requirements are listed below. The higher carbon content of 25MnG raises both yield and tensile strength, at the cost of a slightly lower elongation.

Property 20MnG 25MnG
Minimum yield strength ReL 245 MPa 275 MPa
Tensile strength Rm 415 - 625 MPa 485 - 665 MPa
Minimum elongation A 22 % 20 %
Typical microstructure ferrite and pearlite ferrite and pearlite

In service, 25MnG is selected where the wall thickness calculation calls for a higher allowable stress and the tube can still be formed within the specified bend radii. 20MnG is the more ductile of the two and is often preferred where forming severity, cold bending or welding production rate dominates the decision. Both grades deliver good structural stability at high temperature and are supplied in the normalised or normalised and tempered condition as required by the order.

Selection and Fabrication Notes

Confirm the design allowable stress first: if the wall thickness is driven by strength, 25MnG is the natural choice; if forming and welding dominate, 20MnG is usually sufficient.

Check the bend schedule: tighter bend radii and heavier cold work favour the lower-carbon 20MnG because of its higher elongation.

Weld with matching low-carbon consumables and control heat input; the higher-carbon 25MnG benefits from a qualified procedure with controlled interpass temperature on thicker walls.

Verify heat treatment condition, non-destructive testing and hydrostatic testing against the purchase order, since boiler tubes are pressure parts and traceability is essential.

Do not substitute a boiler grade for a creep-resistant chromium-molybdenum tube where metal temperature enters the creep range.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What do the numbers in 20MnG and 25MnG mean?
They express nominal carbon content in hundredths of a percent, so 20MnG is about 0.20 % carbon and 25MnG about 0.25 % carbon; the Mn shows the manganese addition and G marks boiler service.

Q: Which grade is stronger?
25MnG, with a minimum yield strength of 275 MPa and a tensile range of 485 to 665 MPa, against 245 MPa and 415 to 625 MPa for 20MnG.

Q: Is the difference only in carbon content?
Carbon is the main difference. Manganese, silicon, phosphorus and sulphur limits are effectively the same for both grades, so strength and ductility are what separate them in practice.

Q: Are they the same as the 20G grade?
No. 20G is a plain carbon boiler tube grade, while 20MnG and 25MnG contain roughly twice the manganese and therefore offer higher strength for the same boiler duty.

Q: What standard governs these tubes?
GB 5310-2017, the Chinese standard for seamless steel tubes for high-pressure boilers and superheaters, which fixes composition, mechanical properties, heat treatment and testing.

Q: Can both grades be welded?
Yes. Both are readily welded with matching consumables; the higher-carbon 25MnG calls for tighter control of heat input and interpass temperature, especially on heavier wall sections.