316 vs 316L Stainless Steel Pipe: Carbon, Strength, Welding and Selection

Dec 11, 2023 Leave a message

What 316 and 316L Stainless Steel Pipes Have in Common

Both grades belong to the austenitic chromium-nickel-molybdenum family. Grade 316 corresponds to UNS S31600 and grade 316L to UNS S31603; the L stands for low carbon. Typical chemistry for the two grades, as listed for tube in ASTM A312 and ASTM A213, is 16.0 to 18.0 percent chromium, 10.0 to 14.0 percent nickel and 2.00 to 3.00 percent molybdenum. The molybdenum addition is what separates them from 304 and 304L, because it substantially improves resistance to pitting and crevice corrosion in chloride-bearing media. That is why 316 and 316L pipe are specified for chemical processing, coastal installations, pulp and paper plants, pharmaceutical and food equipment, and heat exchangers in mildly aggressive cooling water.

Both grades are fully austenitic, non-magnetic in the annealed condition, and readily formed, machined and welded. Both are supplied as seamless or welded tube and pipe, in cold-drawn or hot-finished condition, and both are normally delivered in the solution-annealed state.

Carbon Content, Cost and Mechanical Strength

The single chemical difference that drives everything else is carbon. Grade 316 is limited to a maximum of 0.08 percent carbon, while 316L is limited to a maximum of 0.030 percent in the European material designation 1.4404 and to about 0.035 percent for TP316L tube under ASTM A312. Carbon is the element that forms chromium carbides at grain boundaries when an austenitic steel is held or cooled through the sensitising range, roughly 425 to 815 degrees Celsius. Those carbides deplete chromium from the adjacent metal and make the grain boundaries an easy path for intergranular corrosion.

The extra-low carbon content of 316L is obtained by more careful steelmaking and tighter process control, so 316L normally carries a modest price premium over 316 on a per-tonne basis. The premium is usually justified wherever welding is involved, because it removes the need for post-weld heat treatment on many components.

Because carbon is a strong austenite stabiliser and strengthens the austenitic lattice, the lower-carbon 316L has slightly lower minimum strength than 316. The differences are small and predictable, and they matter mainly in thin-wall pressure design.

Property at room temperature 316 (S31600) 316L (S31603)
Carbon, maximum 0.08 % 0.030 to 0.035 %
Minimum yield strength, 0.2 % offset 205 MPa 170 MPa
Minimum tensile strength 515 MPa 485 MPa
Minimum elongation 35 % 35 %
Typical hardness, annealed about 85 HRB about 80 HRB

In elevated-temperature design the position reverses slightly in favour of 316, because the higher carbon content gives better creep and rupture strength. Design codes therefore publish allowable stresses for 316L up to about 425 degrees Celsius, while 316 can be used at somewhat higher metal temperatures. Where the service temperature is high and the medium is not strongly corrosive, 316 is often the better choice; where the metal temperature stays in the moderate range and aggressive media or welding are involved, 316L is preferred.

Welding Behaviour and Intergranular Corrosion

Welding is the classic application in which the two grades separate. In the heat-affected zone of a 316 weld, the metal passes through the sensitising range and chromium carbides can precipitate at grain boundaries. The welded joint of 316 may then be more susceptible to intergranular corrosion than the parent metal, and for corrosive service a post-weld solution anneal at roughly 1,040 to 1,120 degrees Celsius followed by rapid cooling is needed to restore homogeneity.

With 316L the carbon level is too low to form significant carbide networks, so the heat-affected zone stays essentially immune to sensitisation without heat treatment. This makes 316L the practical choice for field-welded pipework, thin-wall tube systems, large fabricated vessels and any component that cannot be annealed after welding. When the two grades are joined together, a 316L filler metal such as ER316L is commonly used so that the weld deposit itself is low in carbon. Fabrication practice also includes cleaning tools between carbon steel and stainless work, purging the root with argon, and pickling and passivating the finished welds to remove heat tint.

Corrosion Resistance and Pitting Resistance Equivalent

In the annealed condition the two grades behave in almost the same way in general corrosion, because they share the same chromium, nickel and molybdenum levels. The difference appears in the welded condition, where 316L retains its resistance while 316 may not unless it has been annealed. For ranking chloride pitting resistance, the pitting resistance equivalent number is calculated as PREN = chromium + 3.3 times molybdenum + 16 times nitrogen. Using typical composition values, 304 falls at about 18 to 19, 316 and 316L at about 24 to 26, and higher-molybdenum grades such as 317L reach about 29 to 30. Neither 316 nor 316L is suitable for continuous immersion in warm seawater; for that duty a higher-molybdenum austenitic grade, a duplex stainless steel or a nickel alloy is normally selected.

How to Choose Between 316 and 316L

Service condition Recommended grade Reason
Field-welded process pipework, no post-weld anneal 316L Avoids sensitisation of the heat-affected zone
Thin-wall tubing for instruments and heat exchangers 316L Good weldability at low wall thickness
High-temperature steam or process service 316 Higher creep and rupture strength
Structural or non-welded components at moderate temperature 316 Higher minimum yield strength, lower cost
Components that will be fully solution annealed after fabrication 316 Heat treatment removes sensitisation risk
General indoor and outdoor architectural use 316 or 316L Both resist atmospheric and mild chloride attack

Purchasing checks should include the mill certificate, the heat number stamped or stencilled on the pipe, dimensional verification and, for critical service, a chemical analysis or a corrosion test on samples from the delivered lot.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is 316L stronger than 316?
No. Reducing carbon lowers the minimum yield strength from 205 MPa to 170 MPa and the minimum tensile strength from 515 MPa to 485 MPa for tube and pipe supplied to ASTM A312.

Q: Can 316 and 316L pipes be welded to each other?
Yes. The joint is common in mixed systems, and a low-carbon filler such as ER316L is normally specified so that the weld deposit is not more susceptible to sensitisation than the lower-carbon parent.

Q: Does 316L need solution annealing after welding?
In most thin-wall and moderate-pressure service the low carbon content prevents sensitisation and post-weld annealing is not required. Heavy sections and highly corrosive duty may still call for a solution anneal at about 1,040 to 1,120 degrees Celsius with rapid cooling.

Q: Are 316 and 316L magnetic?
Both are austenitic and essentially non-magnetic in the annealed condition. Cold working such as bending or drawing can form a small amount of strain-induced martensite, which produces a slight magnetic response.

Q: Which grade is better for coastal or marine environments?
Both resist atmospheric marine exposure well, and 316L has the advantage after welding. For splash zones or continuous seawater immersion, a higher-molybdenum grade such as 317L or a duplex stainless steel is normally required.

Q: What is the price difference between 316 and 316L?
Because of the tighter steelmaking control needed for very low carbon, 316L is usually priced a few percent above 316 for the same size and surface finish. The gap narrows when both grades are in short supply and widens for heavy-wall or special-finish items.